Automation - Université Paris Nanterre Access content directly
Book Sections Year : 2021



Moral or ethical decisions must be made, it seems, by subjects, characterized by their intentionality and, in particular, their autonomy. Thus, delegating them to an automated apparatus would involve either eliminating their moral dimension, or at least limiting it to the morality of its original designer. Such a classical conception hinges on strictly non-dialectical notions of factuality and normativity that often go unquestioned in philosophy of ethics and technology. The claim in this chapter, inspired by Hegel’s and Habermas’s social philosophy, is that the delegation of a moral or ethical decision to an automaton may indeed be considered a dispossession, yet also, under certain circumstances, be the very condition of its effectivity. Indeed, to be normatively satisfactory, concrete interactions imply a motivational, cognitive and organizational load that the subjects involved must bear: without being mediated by factuality, such as the collective power that is being cast in institutional or technical systems – algorithms for instance – these normative demands would remain ineffective. This chapter uses the case of Wikipedia and peer-to-peer file exchange communities, to back its claim and help shift the debate about the morality of “decision-making” machines toward the question of the different forms of delegation to automata.
Fichier principal
Vignette du fichier
Automation between factuality and normativity (book chapter version - final)- Marc-Antoine Pencolé (1).pdf (157.93 Ko) Télécharger le fichier
Origin Files produced by the author(s)

Dates and versions

hal-03670665 , version 1 (18-05-2022)



Marc-Antoine Pencolé. Automation: Between Factuality and Normativity. Susanna Lindberg; Hanna-Riika Roine. The Ethos of Digital Environments: Technology, Literary Theory and Philosophy, Routledge, pp.151-160, 2021, 9780367643270. ⟨10.4324/9781003123996⟩. ⟨hal-03670665⟩
40 View
88 Download



Gmail Mastodon Facebook X LinkedIn More